Its time to build a deck for EDH.
I played Sisters of Stone Death as my commander some time ago, but that deck was mostly just my former Nath of the Gilt-Leaf, who got usurped by the sisters after being in the deck and noticing that they were fun. So, it may have taken me almost a year, but here we are. Usurping Nath’s deck wasn’t that good an idea, because Sisters need a lot of mana, whereas Nath isn’t that greedy for an EDH deck. With a deck built around the sisters, this has a much better chance of thriving. After three games with this deck (one win), its fun to play, although not necessarily very competitive (which it doesn’t necessarily need to be).
So, lets go through the cards. If you want to take a better look at the deck, I put it up on TappedOut.
The Gorgon Package
First, we obviously have the sisters
but she also brought her extended family.
They might be from three different planes, but maybe some unthinking planeswalker put them there. Of course, Vraska can do by herself. Maybe she’s the secret power behind the throne.
All in all, these are mostly control creatures. Mender is just a little bit of recursion and Reaper is about controlling your draws, although she’s a bit too hard to control to make that very profitable in EDH. Gladly, the family is there to help, Auntie Hythonia sometimes giving quite a few scrys at the same time. Xathrid Gorgon has a very special role as she can make quite a few difficult monsters (such as Ulamog, the Infinite Gyre) if not harmless, at least less harmful.
Pest Control Package
Although our ladies abover are doing a pretty good job already, keeping other players devoid of creatures is always good. Therefore this small suite of other creatures who are more or less doing the same thing. Besides the good, ole Assassin, these can also get very aggressive. Especially considering the evasion.
Couple of sweepers. I’ve found two to be plenty, with the Rock cards there mostly for token strategies, but also for just sweeping things other than creatures.
… and sometimes you don’t want to kill everything. I’d like to add more, but this was all I had room for. Consuming Vapors might be problematic, but you just need something for the aforementioned Ulamog. Also, lifegain can be very good at times, although this particular deck doesn’t really use life as a resource.
… and there’s Liliana. I could put her somewhere else, but she’s in the deck mostly as “pest control”. Also, since Sisters are an excellent mana dump, keeping everyone out of cards in hand is a pretty good tactic.
Card Advantage, Recursion and Tutoring
More card advantage would be good. However, we do have the Sisters and therefore we’ll always have something to put our mana into (unless they get tucked). Garruk can do many things, but in EDH he’s usually used best as a very cheap draw spell. If he’s on the board with Sisters, we can get seven cards for five mana. Very effective. With all the sweepers in the format, Harvester can also draw plenty of cards with only six mana.
With some people playing milling strategies in our meta, recursion is just great. Especially Creeping Renaissance, since it has flashback and can get you plenty of stuff after a poorly thought out Traumatize. Praetor’s Counsel in hand is even better, but the Renaissance just has that much better chance of hitting the graveyard at an opportune moment. Burial and Stronghold give us recurring advantage and can be really good. Witness is there just for the early game, but can be a good combo with any other recursion we have.
.. and the tutoring. This deck has a lot of tools, but often just a couple of them. A few tutors help. Ambition might be a bit unnecessary, as we don’t really have game winning two card combos or anything like that, so maybe it would be better to lose it, but it feels fine. The flashback is very expensive, but again, there’s some milling in our meta, so flashing it back can be really good. The Demon is also a very good body.
I don’t know where to put this primordial exactly, but we’re mostly talking card advantage here and I think it belongs here more than the other categories. Can also disrupt opponent nicely, if they try to bring something to their graveyard for a combo.
Plenty of ramp. Our commander is pretty greedy with mana, so to get her online in a decent amount of turns, we need to ramp. A lot. I don’t like to use manarocks in this deck. I don’t have any artifacts in the deck, which makes certain cards dead against us (thus basically making our opponents artifact hate work for us). Plenty of creatures, because bodies are easily reused with our recursion, and plenty of sorceries to get our mana. Of course, another Liliana, which I even wrote an article about. She’s mostly used to get the swamps, with not much point in going for ultimate (although, I’m happy to do it). The second ability can be very strong in the late game, as it can kill creatures that would otherwise be very difficult to handle. Again, once nice body in the group with the much hated Vorinclex.
Liliana of the Dark Realms
Vorinclex, Voice of Hunger
Khalni Heart Expedition
Generally, its good to be able to destroy non-creature permanents, so some cards for exactly that purpose. Again, mostly with bodies, as those can be recycled. Also, Acidic Slime trades up and the two others have great bodies as well. Primordial also serves the purpose of ramping even more. Bramblecrush and Rain of Thorns are for extra flexibility. Cremate is just the greatest EDH-card ever. I’m not even kidding. There are so many recursion based combos and this card can disrupt them with one mana and it also replenishes itself. Even if none of your enemies play recursion (which has never happened), you’ll be able to cycle it with only mana.
Also, I have some extra ways of protecting my creatures. Sheltering Word can be a big blowout, if you opponent has been keeping that one spot removal in his hand to stop your big attack with Sisters. Also, the life is nice. Asceticism and Broken Fall are there just to keep my creature alive. Broken Fall is especially good, since its very hard to destroy as long as there’s at least on targetable creature on the battlefield.
Mostly just mana, but with two more utility lands (some were in the lists above). Bojuka Bog is a staple in these decks, again with all the recursion running rampant. Grim Backwoods isn’t as obvious a choice, but its actually probably my most tutored card as it can be very good against tucking. Drawing cards is often a good idea too and if I have recursion, it can be a great part of a ad-hoc combo.
Plenty of basics, just to have plenty of lands to find with my ramp cards. Still, I’ve run out a couple of times.
Previously I’ve talked about my process of designing these decks. Cards I hadn’t used before or in a long time include the Theros Gorgons, Grim Backwoods, Asceticism, Broken Fall and Sheltering Word. Thusfar they all seem very good, although Asceticism has a habit of getting destroyed very quickly.
I’ve played this deck three times now with one win. Granted, not all the opposing decks were very competitive, but I think this deck strikes a good balance of being fun to play and being a real threat, without being oppressive.